Carmine's Italian Deli

Located in the heart of Jersey City, Carmine's Italian Deli is a beloved Italian restaurant that masterfully captures the essence of classic Italian flavors with a fresh, deli twist. From the moment you step inside, the authentic aromas of slow-cooked sauces, roasted peppers, and fresh mozzarella greet you, inviting an unforgettable culinary experience in a cozy, no-frills setting.

Specializing in a wide range of Italian deli favorites and hearty hot platters, Carmine’s menu boasts standout dishes like the tender Chicken Marsala bathed in a rich, wine-infused sauce, and the comforting Chicken Parmigiana served alongside perfectly cooked linguini. For sandwich enthusiasts, the Prosciutto Sandwich and Italian Sandwich are crafted with layers of high-quality meats by the pound—such as sweet prosciutto and robust Genoa salami—paired with creamy cheeses like Parmigiano Reggiano and Auricchio Provolone that elevate every bite.

The deli is especially known for its Chicken Cutlet specialties. As one satisfied customer, Blake Lew-Merwin, enthuses, the chicken cutlet is “obviously made fresh and in house,” boasting a delightful crunch and juicy interior complemented by melting mozzarella and roasted peppers atop garlic bread with a drizzle of balsamic vinegar—a combination so indulgent, it leaves a lasting impression that words alone can’t capture. The careful attention to ingredient quality—from fresh mozzarella to rich olive oil—shines through in every meal.

Carmine’s dedication to flavorful, comforting food extends beyond just sandwiches and hot platters. The Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken offers a creamy, tangy sauce that perfectly balances with tender pasta and chunks of succulent chicken, while the Eggplant Parmigiana and Rollatini provide delicious vegetarian options bursting with rich tomato sauce and melted cheese.

Despite its limited seating and modest location at 165 Mallory Ave, the atmosphere remains warm and welcoming with an emphasis on genuine hospitality. Customers like Helen Pham have appreciated both the consistently fresh flavors and the attentive service that make Carmine's feel like a cherished neighborhood gem. Whether grabbing a grilled chicken Caesar wrap or indulging in the house-specialty Roast Beef & Fresh Mozzarella sandwich, patrons consistently praise the reliability and freshness of each dish, with many returning time and again to satisfy their cravings.

A practical note: Carmine’s operates on a cash-only basis, preserving its authentic deli vibe, and while seating is limited and there are no restrooms on site, the quality of food and community feel more than make up for it. With pricing that delivers exceptional value—such as $10 hot platters that rival fine dining quality—this spot is perfect for a casual lunch stop or a comforting takeout meal.

In summation, Carmine's Italian Deli offers a flavorful journey through Italian classics with the unmistakable charm of a genuine deli. It’s a place where every plate tells a story of fresh ingredients, careful preparation, and a passion for delivering honest, satisfying meals. For anyone in Jersey City craving authentic Italian deli flavors, Carmine’s stands out as an unmissable, reliable destination.

Contact Information:
165 Mallory Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07304, United States
Phone: +1 201-434-5155